The Pros and Cons of Mental Health Diagnosis

Diagnosing mental illness is complex, involving evaluations of psychological symptoms to identify a diagnosis. It can be tough to distinguish between normal human behaviors and more severe behavioral patterns. A mental health diagnosis is essential to determine the severity of a mental illness, improve patient care and support well-being. Still, assigning a label to something can carry some risks, such as a negative stigma. This post will explore the pros and cons of mental health diagnosis to understand better its value for psychiatrists, parents, teens, and everyone affected by mental illness.

What is Mental Health Diagnosis?

A mental health diagnosis is a clinical assessment made by a mental health professional to determine whether a person meets the criteria for a specific mental health disorder or condition. Mental health diagnoses are based on the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5), which the American Psychiatric Association publishes.

A mental health diagnosis is made after a comprehensive psychiatric evaluation that includes a clinical interview, a review of the person’s medical history, and a discussion of their symptoms and impact on daily life. A mental health professional may also use standardized assessments and rating scales to help with the diagnostic process.

The purpose of a mental health diagnosis is to provide a framework for understanding a person’s symptoms and to guide the selection of appropriate treatments. It can also help mental health professionals communicate with each other about a person’s condition and ensure that they receive the most effective care.

It’s important to note that a mental health diagnosis is not a label or a judgment of a person’s character or worth. Instead, it is a tool to help mental health professionals provide the best care possible and improve a person’s quality of life.

Pros of Mental Health Diagnosis:

Mental health diagnosis is widely beneficial to people with psychiatric issues or questions concerning their mental well-being. The diagnostic process assigns a name to a group of symptoms, provides a common language, and can communicate with practitioners to create a treatment plan.  Here are the positive aspects of obtaining a mental health diagnosis:

• Precise diagnoses assist individuals in identifying treatments supported by empirical evidence, with a proven track record of reducing symptoms and alleviating discomfort. For instance, Response Prevention and Exposure Therapy are highly effective for patients with Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD).
• The precision of diagnosis aids in securing educational or occupational support and obtaining suitable medication.
• It Instills hope and alleviates the anxiety associated with the unknown.
• It enables individuals to connect with others experiencing the same issue.
• Aids in accessing additional resources and services such as financial assistance and insurance reimbursement.
• If a patient switches psychologists, this diagnosis aids in pinpointing or further exploring the problem and continuing or adjusting the treatment plan.
• Patients don’t experience a sense of isolation as they realize that others also suffer from the same condition, even before their diagnosis.
• Having an explicit name for the condition makes it easier to describe, empowering the treatment team or individual practitioner to provide proper treatment, care, and explanation for behaviors.
• Diagnosis facilitates targeted interventions, as psychologists and psychiatrists can develop a general idea of appropriate treatment options. Following diagnosis, most practitioners tend to prescribe similar types of interventions.
• The patient regards the prescription with importance and adheres to it, leading to a sense of accountability and active pursuit of treatment.
• A diagnosis provides an understanding of the problem, allowing individuals to grasp the issue rather than perceiving themselves as insane or confused about their relationship with friends, family, and society.

Cons of Mental Health Diagnosis:

Mental health diagnosis is a complex psychological process that can have adverse or conflicting outcomes. Because diagnosis relies heavily on the person to accurately describe and  self-report symptoms, the label of the disorder can vary between clinicians.  The downside of mental health diagnosis can include:

• Labels do not explain the underlying causes of mental health issues.  The label provides  a place to start while considering historical, environmental, and neurological factors or recent traumatic events.
• Diagnosis can vary over time, even when symptoms are similar, depending on the historical records, the patient’s present mood, and age. 
• A diagnosis can vary between clinicians causing further confusion for the patient.
• Being labeled with a mental disorder can cause individuals to feel abnormal or isolated.
• When sharing the diagnosis with others, they may falsely believe all mental illnesses are associated with psychotic and violent behavior. 
• The diagnosis and the supporting medication can negatively impact obtaining licenses and jobs, particularly jobs requiring you to operate heavy machinery or equipment.  An employer can request a drug screening to ensure the medication does not negatively impact your ability to perform the job safely.
• In some cases, an illness can be exacerbated by over-identifying with it. For example, a parent may discourage an impulsive child diagnosed with ADHD from engaging in new experiences, or an individual may choose isolation for fear of being different.
• Diagnoses can disregard the influence of short-term factors such as a recent loss, family environment, or social factors. But a good psychiatrist or clinician can determine neurological and psychiatric disorders vs. short-term life-changing events and stressors.
• The diagnosis is limited by its reliance on Western explanations and disregard for other cultural perspectives. For example, in many indigenous cultures, mental health is often viewed in the context of one’s relationship with the natural environment, community, and ancestors. The Western model of mental health diagnosis focuses on individual pathology and symptomatology and tends to overlook these broader cultural and social factors. This can result in misdiagnosis or ineffective treatment approaches for people from different cultural backgrounds.
• Globally, the accuracy of diagnostic criteria can be influenced by various factors such as access to resources due to economic class, educational influences, and biases within the field. While psychological assessments and structured interviews can increase accuracy, they can also be time-consuming and costly.
• Assigning labels to mental health issues may not be the answer. Instead of focusing on labeling the problem, many qualified psychotherapists and psychiatrists have enough experience to understand the symptoms quickly and the underlying causes to develop a treatment plan that best suits the patient’s needs.

The Alternatives to Mental Health Diagnoses

Mental health can be an intimidating and alienating realm for many people. Psychiatric evaluations, a standard for understanding and diagnosing mental health problems in modern society, can be conducted within 10 – 15 minutes or a long series of tests and psychiatric interviews. Depending on the severity, psychiatric evaluations are not the only way to better understand or diagnose mental illnesses. Psychology and psychiatry offer a variety of additional tools, such as psychiatric empathy exams, psychological assessments, cognitive-behavioral therapy, psychotherapy, systems thinking methods, and group therapies, that can further help uncover the root issues behind a person’s emotional distress. All these alternatives provide practical ways to develop a holistic view of an individual’s emotional state while exploring potential underlying causes. Moreover, these alternatives create an equally valid means to explore psychological issues without fear of alienation.  It is important to remember these other therapies, instead of an evaluation, are not a substitute for seeking the help of a psychiatrist or clinician when considering self-harm or harming others in emergencies.

Where to Find Help

If you need help, knowing where to turn can often feel overwhelming. There is a wide variety of resources available that are here to assist you. You don’t need a diagnosis:

• Talk to a trusted friend, family member, teacher, or counselor. Sometimes simply sharing your thoughts and feelings with someone can help you feel better.
• Find support online: Many online communities and resources are available where you can connect with others experiencing similar challenges. You can search for support groups, forums, or social media groups relevant to your needs.
• Talk to your school or work: Many schools and workplaces have mental health resources, such as counseling services or employee assistance programs. You can reach out to them for support and guidance.
• Look after yourself: Self-care is essential for maintaining good mental health. This can include getting enough sleep, eating well, exercising regularly, and practicing relaxation techniques such as meditation or deep breathing.
• Seek support from The Mental Health Management Group: MHMG is a healthcare provider that specializes in mental health services. They offer various services, including assessing, diagnosing, and treating mental health conditions. You can contact them to schedule an appointment with a mental health professional who can provide the support and treatment you need.

Conclusion

Mental health diagnoses are critical to understanding and managing symptoms that cause distress, but they are not the only approach we can take. We can learn coping strategies and seek out alternative mental health treatments without relying on labels imposed by diagnosis. Many resources are available to support individuals experiencing emotional difficulties, including therapy and support groups. Finding the right treatment plan or combination of treatments is a matter of personal preference and individual needs. Ultimately, being informed about mental health diagnoses is the first step in creating lasting wellness for ourselves and those around us. Creating a life where we feel supported, connected, and safe is possible- a journey worth taking.

FAQs